October 14, 2026
A petroleum refiner, a biofuel producer, and a farmer share a meal at a restaurant. When the check comes, they all argue over how to split the tab. This is a great analogy for the fight over Small Refinery Exemptions (SREs). They are all Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) participants, and between EPA waivers and reallocations followed by court rulings, the tab is passed back and forth between refineries or biofuel producers and the farm groups who supply the feedstock.
Petroleum refiners see SREs as a way to help small refineries that can’t absorb RFS compliance costs the way larger ones can. Biofuel producers and farm groups see lost demand for ethanol, biodiesel and renewable fuels, along with the corn and soybeans behind them, every time gallons are waived and not replaced.
Reallocation has become EPA’s way of passing the check: it adds waived gallons back into the standards other obligated parties must meet in the future. When and how much EPA reallocates is often as contested as the exemptions themselves.
The two August 2026 SRE decisions, and the court challenges by Renewable Fuels Association (RFA) that followed within weeks, are the newest chapter in a story that has been playing out for nearly two decades.
Each of these opposing actions have ripple effects in RIN markets, making it critical for all RFS participants to anticipate how exemptions, court rulings and reallocations affect their RIN position.
RFA filed two petitions that now join more than 30 petitions filed with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit regarding EPA small refinery exemptions (SREs) from the RFS blending mandates.
Two Announcements, Two Doors Opened
Both of EPA’s August announcements were doors for RFA and other groups to challenge in court.
Reallocation Passes the Bill Back
When EPA announced the waivers on Aug. 31, it also shared plans to reallocate all waived gallons by October. And it did yesterday. So now, it’s the petroleum industry’s turn to push back.
Challenging the Foundation EPA Laid Out
Along with EPA’s Aug. 3 waivers, it announced a foundation for the decision and future ones. The foundation laid out EPA’s approach to evaluating and issuing SREs in light of all the court rulings, including the April 7, 2026 D.C. Circuit Court decision rejecting EPA’s requirement that refineries demonstrate eligibility across consecutive years.
This new EPA foundation appears to be RFA’s target, finding the Department of Energy (DOE) matrix too lenient. RFA President and CEO Geoff Cooper stating, “These exemptions are unjustified and based on flawed analysis by the Department of Energy.”
EPA’s new foundation includes:
- Assess eligibility annually, including the average aggregate daily throughput (75,000 barrels/day).
- Use the matrix from the Department of Energy (DOE) Small Refinery Study to determine whether the small refinery is experiencing economic hardship, and to what degree.
- Consider other economic factors in the broader context of the refining industry and the RFS.
- If waiver is warranted, determine whether partial or full based on DOE data.
- Then, issue decisions.
In this latest petition, RFA also requested the court hold off on its newly filed challenge until the case around last year’s waivers are resolved. According to Cooper, “Our new filing ensures the August 2026 exemptions are properly preserved for judicial review while allowing the court to resolve the fundamental legal issues first.”
While EPA intended to provide clarity on how it will consider remaining and future waiver applications, RFA is challenging that foundation.
What Comes Next for SREs and Reallocation
Yesterday, Oct. 13, EPA announced two options to reallocate 100 percent of the waived gallons: One approach is to divide the additional volume between 2026 and 2027 compliance years, while the other approach is to allocate all of the volume to the 2027 compliance year. Keep in mind, EPA is taking public comments through Dec. 4, 2026. If it becomes a final rule, those gallons shift to other obligated parties. If they aren’t, then the biofuel demand behind those gallons, are gone.
If history is any guide, no single ruling will close the book on SREs. Administrations and court rulings have constantly forced the refining industry and the biofuels and agricultural sectors to pass the tab back and forth. What stays constant is the need to understand how each development affects RFS participants. We’ll keep following the challenges and reallocation decisions, and share what they mean for your RIN Management strategy.
– Rhonda O’Connor, Director of Operations, Compliance & Communications